Indians in the US whip Pakistanis

Big gaps in education, wealth among South Asians in US

A study of South Asians in the US has revealed huge disparities in their education, employment and wealth.

Compared to the general population, South Asians in the US have the highest percentage of people with advanced degrees, but they also have a higher percentage of people with less than a fifth grade education, the study found.

The report, "Making data count", prepared by the Chicago-based South Asian American Policy and Research Institute (SAAPRI), compares the status of major South Asian groups with other Asian Americans and the US population, as revealed by the 2000 census.

Though the South Asian median household income at $50,723 is higher than the national median income of $41,994, they have high poverty levels among families, the elderly and children. South Asian women are more disadvantaged, with lower education, income and employment rates than men.

"There are sections of the community who are really disadvantaged," said Ann Kalayil, who along with Padma Rangaswamy, authored the report.

"We realised that in spite of having such a vibrant community with so many social, professional and religious organisations, we still did not have an institution devoted to understanding issues from a strictly policy making perspective," said Kalayil.

"SAAPRI was established to fill the gap. There are so many areas in which we can advocate for reform - in education, social services, civil rights - but without hard data and solid research to back up our demands, we cannot expect to influence public policy," she added.

Kalayil, Rangaswamy and K Sujata founded SAAPRI.

Among other findings of the report:

* The Asian American population has tripled in size over the last two decades, from 3.4 million in 1980 to 10.2 million in 2000. Among the major Asian American sub-groups, Indians recorded the highest growth rate of 106 per cent between 1990 and 2000.

* The South Asian American population is young and with a median age of 31 years, and, like most new immigrant populations in the US, has more males (53 percent) than females (47 per cent). The ratio of males to females and the percentage of youths under 18 are higher among Pakistanis and Bangladeshis than among Indians and Sri Lankans.

*An overwhelming majority of South Asians speak a language other than English at home. Nearly one quarter, or 416,530 speak English "less than very well".

* Between one-third and two-thirds of South Asians are in the management, professional and related categories, with Indians and Sri Lankans (60 per cent and 57 per cent respectively) having a significantly higher percentage than Pakistanis and Bangladeshis.

* Within the South Asian population, Indians and Sri Lankans have higher incomes than the Pakistanis and Bangladeshis. Both male and female median earnings are particularly low for Bangladeshis at $30,901 for men and $19,308 for women.

* Nearly one in four Bangladeshi (25 percent) and one in five Pakistani (20 percent) children live below the poverty line compared to less than one in six for the general population.

The increasing numbers in the South Asian community should translate into a greater presence in the political mainstream and in efforts to reform immigration laws and fight hate crimes and discrimination, Kalayil said.

"Post-9/11, South Asians are targeted because they look different. If I had a bank where I could put a dollar every time someone asked me where I was from (implying when am I going back), I would have a lot of money," she said.